Industrial Minerals and Mining Sector Outlook — September 2026
This sector outlook compares Industrial Minerals and Mining operating models — bulk mineral producers, completions and pressure-pumping services, and adjacent models — on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), precedent transactions and strategic positioning.
For information only. Not an appraisal or a fairness opinion.
What moved since: Industrial Minerals and Mining M&A update, 14–28 September 2026
Key figures
- Sector median valuation
- 6.9x
- EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), rated names
- Premium-end valuation
- 23.1x
- Highest rated EV / EBITDA (CY2027E)
- Discount-end valuation
- 5.5x
- Lowest rated EV / EBITDA (CY2027E)
- Bulk mineral producers share
- 40%
- Share of approved companies
Read the report
1 / 20 · Industrial Minerals: A Premium End, a Discount End, and the Operating Gap Between Them
Executive summary
Forward EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) coverage across this peer set is narrow, with rated multiples ranging from 23.1x at the premium end to 5.5x at the discount end around a 6.9x sector median. The premium is associated with forecast growth rather than current margin, and business model shapes valuation ahead of scale. Precedent transactions, including Atlas Energy Solutions Inc.'s announced $450M transaction for Hi-Crush Inc., show strategic fit driving deal terms. Durable value still depends on delivered economics and contract quality, not multiple alone.
Key findings
- Rated EV/EBITDA (CY2027E) spans 23.1x at the premium end to 5.5x at the discount end.
- Bulk mineral producers make up 40% of the approved peer set.
- The observed premium is associated with forecast growth, not current margin.
- Precedent deals span mineral supply, processing and adjacent service integration.
What each page shows
The analyst’s walkthrough of the deck, page by page.
- 01MATERIALS › MATERIALS › INDUSTRIAL MINERALS AND MINING
Industrial Minerals: A Premium End, a Discount End, and the Operating Gap Between Them
Cover slide introducing the September 2026 Industrial Minerals and Mining sector outlook and its central framing.
We open this review of Industrial Minerals and Mining as of September 28, 2026, framed around a premium end, a discount end and the operating gap between them. The pages that follow walk through where that gap originates and what closes it.
Everything on this page
MATERIALS › MATERIALS › INDUSTRIAL MINERALS AND MINING Industrial Minerals: A Premium End, a Discount End, and the Operating Gap Between Them This report shows how earnings visibility, delivered economics and strategic fit separate the peer set. September 2026 · Prepared by NeuraCap AI · Confidential Market data as of 2026-09-28 · primary valuation basis EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 1
- 02CONTENTS
What This Report Covers
Contents page listing the report's five numbered sections plus the appendix.
This report runs five sections plus an appendix, starting with the bottom line so a reader who stops after section one still gets the full story. From there we move through the landscape, valuation and situations, precedent transactions and the strategic implications for owners and operators.
Everything on this page
CONTENTS What This Report Covers 01 The Bottom Line Industrial Minerals and Mining Splits Across Distinct Valuation Lanes 02 The Landscape Different Mineral Models Face Different Value Tests 03 Valuation & Situations The Premium Sits with Forecast Growth Despite Lower Margin 04 Precedent Transactions What Buyers Agreed to Pay Reflects Asset Fit and Strategic Reach 05 Strategic Implications Strengthen Delivered Economics Before Choosing the Capital Path 06 Appendix Comparables Detail, Methodology, Sources and Assumptions Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 2
- 0301 · THE BOTTOM LINE
Industrial Minerals and Mining Splits Between Bulk Minerals, Completions Services and Adjacent Models
The bottom-line page summarizes how the approved peer set splits by business model and valuation level on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E).
We size this story on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), the basis validated coverage supports across this peer set. The rated names span a wide range, from 23.1x at the premium end to 5.5x at the discount end, and bulk mineral producers alone account for 40% of the approved companies. That spread tells us business model and forecast growth, not scale, separate the premium from the discount end. So the sections that follow test what closes that gap.
Everything on this page
01 · THE BOTTOM LINE Industrial Minerals and Mining Splits Between Bulk Minerals, Completions Services and Adjacent Models The full story on one page · figures on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), market data as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Primary valuation basis: EV / EBITDA on CY2027E consensus (4 of 10 companies eligible; multiples failing the platform's plausibility gates are excluded, never plotted). Practitioners price this industry on EV / EBITDA rather than EV / Revenue; validated coverage supports the industry standard (6 of 10 companies), so this report follows it. Qualitative characterisations are NeuraCap views. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 3 1 Forecast Earnings Support a Narrow Valuation Set The 4 names with a forward EV / EBITDA estimate sit within 10 approved companies. Their range runs from 23.1x at the premium end to 5.5x at the discount end. 2 Business Model Comes Before Sector Average Bulk non-metallic mineral producers represent 40% of the approved companies. Completions and pressure pumping services account for 3 of 10, placing delivered cost and last-mile logistics at the centre of their value case. 3 Margin Alone Does Not Place a Name Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. (AESI) carries a 20% margin, while ProFrac Holding Corp. (ACDC) carries 16%. Both sit in the core range, making contract coverage and delivered economics important areas for diligence. 4 The Deals Cluster Around Clear Strategic Fit The 8 recorded transactions span mineral supply, processing and adjacent service integration. Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. (AESI) agreed to an announced $450M transaction for Hi-Crush Inc., showing the scale attached to an in-segment combination. 6.9x Sector median EV/EBITDA CY2027E consensus · 4 rated of 10 companies 23.1x Premium end EV/EBITDA vs 5.5x at the discount end top quartile (n=1) against bottom quartile (n=1) on EV/EBITDA — the spread the report explains 8 Transactions with disclosed terms 31 recorded in this tier · 1 told as case studies, the full list in the appendix
- 04SECTION 02
02
Section divider introducing the market-map and landscape pages on operating models.
Reserve quality, delivered reach and downstream position price differently across this peer set. We use the next pages to map where each operating model sits before turning to valuation.
Everything on this page
SECTION 02 02 THE LANDSCAPE Different Mineral Models Face Different Value Tests Reserve quality, delivered reach and downstream position matter differently across the peer set. 02 of 06 Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 4
- 0502 · MARKET MAP
Valuation Sits at Different Levels Across the Three Operating Models
Median EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) by business-segment group across the approved companies.
We group the approved companies by business segment and compare median EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) across each. The sector median sits at 6.9x, and the groups do not cluster around it evenly. That separation is the first sign that operating model, not simply scale, sets the valuation floor and ceiling here. So the next page unpacks what each group actually does.
Everything on this page
02 · MARKET MAP Valuation Sits at Different Levels Across the Three Operating Models 10 approved companies grouped by business segment · median EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) per group · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Segment grouping follows the platform's classification; group medians on rated names only. "Why it matters" lines are NeuraCap views. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 5 BULK NON-METALLIC MINERAL PRODUCERS — BORATES, TALC AND KAOLIN 4 cos 23.1x · 1 rated MP Materials (MP) Compass Minerals (CMP) Critical Metals (CRML) NioCorp (NB) Reserve quality, beneficiation and downstream position shape how these assets compare. ADJACENT: COMPLETIONS AND PRESSURE PUMPING SERVICES 3 cos median 6.9x Atlas Energy (AESI) ProFrac Holding (ACDC) Smart Sand (SND) In-basin supply, proppant intensity and last-mile logistics frame the earnings case. ADJACENT MODELS 3 cos 5.5x · 1 rated ICL Group (ICL) Oil-Dri (ODC) NACCO Industries (NC) Fertilizer minerals, formulated products and mine management require asset-specific comparisons.
- 0602 · LANDSCAPE
Delivered Reach and Product Position Separate the Three Groups
Describes what each of the three operating-model groups does and why delivered reach and product position matter to their valuation.
Delivered reach and product position separate bulk mineral producers, completions and pressure-pumping services, and adjacent models. Each group carries a different mix of contract structure and logistics exposure that feeds into the medians shown here. Understanding what each group actually does is the foundation for reading the valuation pages that follow. So we treat operating model as the first filter before margin or growth.
Everything on this page
02 · LANDSCAPE Delivered Reach and Product Position Separate the Three Groups Segment view of the approved universe · EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) medians on rated names · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. "What they do / why it matters" is a NeuraCap view. Full company-level detail in the appendix and companion tables. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 6 Segment n Share of universe Median EV/EBITDA Names to know What they do — and why it matters Bulk non-metallic mineral producers — borates, talc and kaolin 4 40% 23.1x n=1 MP Materials Corp. (MP) · Compass Minerals International, Inc. (CMP) · +2 more Reserve economics set the frame. This group represents 40% of the approved companies. Mine life, grade, permitting and the path from run-of-mine material through beneficiation shape the relevant comparison. Adjacent: completions and pressure pumping services 3 30% 6.9x Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. (AESI) · ProFrac Holding Corp. (ACDC) · +1 more Logistics sit beside the mine. This group represents 30% of the approved companies. In-basin supply, terminals and last-mile logistics influence delivered cost per ton and customer reach. Adjacent models 3 30% 5.5x n=1 ICL Group Ltd (ICL) · Oil-Dri Corporation of America (ODC) · +1 more Asset specifics outweigh labels. These 3 approved companies span fertilizer minerals, formulated mineral products and mine management. Their value cases depend on different catchments, customer uses and capital requirements.
- 07SECTION 03
03
Section divider introducing the public-market valuation analysis.
The premium in this peer set sits with forecast growth despite lower current margin, which raises the bar for durability. The next pages test that premium against margin, growth and situational positioning.
Everything on this page
SECTION 03 03 VALUATION & SITUATIONS The Premium Sits with Forecast Growth Despite Lower Margin The forward earnings lens already credits forecasts, raising the test for durability. 03 of 06 Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 7
- 0803 · PUBLIC MARKET VALUATION
Forecast Growth Marks the Gap Between the Two Ends of the Range
Ranks the rated companies on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) around the sector median.
Among the rated companies, EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) runs from the premium end to the discount end around a 6.9x sector median. Forecast growth marks the gap between those two ends of the range, not current profitability alone. That is the central valuation finding of this report. So the next page asks whether margin and growth actually explain the ordering.
Everything on this page
03 · PUBLIC MARKET VALUATION Forecast Growth Marks the Gap Between the Two Ends of the Range EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) · all 4 rated companies, sorted descending · sector median 6.9x · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Primary valuation basis: EV / EBITDA on CY2027E consensus (4 of 10 companies eligible; multiples failing the platform's plausibility gates are excluded, never plotted). Practitioners price this industry on EV / EBITDA rather than EV / Revenue; validated coverage supports the industry standard (6 of 10 companies), so this report follows it. Tier zones are NeuraCap groupings cut at the rated set's quartiles; every multiple quoted on this page is a median on the same EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) basis. Panel commentary is a NeuraCap view. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 8 PREMIUM · median 23.1x CORE · median 6.9x DISCOUNT · median 5.5x Sector median 6.9x WHAT SEPARATES THE TWO ENDS The top carries forecast growth. Among the 4 names with a forward EV / EBITDA estimate, MP Materials Corp. (MP) sits at the premium-end 23.1x with 77% growth, versus ICL Group Ltd (ICL) at the discount-end 5.5x with 3% growth. Margin does not sort them. Among the 4 names with a forward EV / EBITDA estimate, MP Materials Corp. (MP) carries a 7% margin, while ICL Group Ltd (ICL) carries 21%. The observed valuation order runs opposite to the margin order. Forward value raises the bar. A forward EV / EBITDA multiple already credits forecast earnings. A premium that holds on this basis places greater weight on the durability of growth, operating delivery and funding capacity.
- 0903 · VALUATION DRIVERS
Profitability Alone Does Not Sort the Four Forward-Valued Names
Tests whether revenue-growth and EBITDA-margin cohorts sort the rated companies' median multiples.
We split the rated names into growth and margin cohorts at their respective covered medians and compare median EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) across each cut. Profitability alone does not sort the four forward-valued names cleanly. That is an association we observe in the data, not a causal claim, and it points toward forecast growth as the stronger driver of the premium. So diligence should test the durability of that growth rather than assume margin will catch up.
Everything on this page
03 · VALUATION DRIVERS Profitability Alone Does Not Sort the Four Forward-Valued Names Median EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) by revenue-growth cohort and by EBITDA-margin cohort (each split at its covered median) · rated names with estimates · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Cohort medians on rated names with the required estimates (faster n=0; slower n=0; higher-margin n=0; lower-margin n=0). Driver readings are NeuraCap views on the supplied data — association, not causation. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 9 The Margin Spread Crosses the Range On the 4 names with a forward EV / EBITDA estimate, MP Materials Corp. (MP) carries a 7% margin at the top of the range, while ICL Group Ltd (ICL) carries 21% at the bottom. Forecast Growth Aligns with the Endpoints On the 4 names with a forward EV / EBITDA estimate, MP Materials Corp. (MP) carries 77% growth and ICL Group Ltd (ICL) carries 3%. This is an observed association, not evidence that growth alone sets valuation. Core Peers Still Need Operating Distinction Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. (AESI) carries a 20% margin versus 16% for ProFrac Holding Corp. (ACDC). For completions-linked models, delivered cost, take-or-pay coverage and last-mile logistics remain practical points of separation.
- 1003 · SITUATION MAP
Value Sits in Four Distinct Positions Across Margin and Multiple
Maps the rated companies into quadrants cut on EV / EBITDA versus the sector median and EBITDA margin versus the covered median.
We cut the rated set on EV / EBITDA against the 6.9x sector median and on EBITDA margin against the 18% covered median, producing four distinct positions. These are observations on where each name sits today, not recommendations to buy or sell. The pattern shows that margin and multiple do not move together in this peer set. So the value question becomes which quadrant a given asset can move toward, and why.
Everything on this page
03 · SITUATION MAP Value Sits in Four Distinct Positions Across Margin and Multiple Cut on EV / EBITDA vs the sector median (6.9x) (rows) and EBITDA margin vs the covered median (18%) (columns) · observations, not recommendations Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Situation boundaries are the cohort's own medians (Directional, NeuraCap view). This page characterises situations; it does not recommend buying or selling any security. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 10 Higher Multiple, Higher Margin Above-median multiple · above-median EBITDA margin 1 names Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. (AESI) Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. (AESI) sits above both reference lines. The operating priority is to protect delivered economics and contract quality while allocating capital selectively. Higher Multiple, Lower Margin Above-median multiple · below-median EBITDA margin 1 names MP Materials Corp. (MP) MP Materials Corp. (MP) sits above the valuation reference and below the margin reference. The key test is whether forecast growth converts into durable earnings through processing progress and operating delivery. Lower Multiple, Higher Margin Below-median multiple · above-median EBITDA margin 1 names ICL Group Ltd (ICL) ICL Group Ltd (ICL) sits below the valuation reference and above the margin reference. The value question is whether its earnings mix, market exposure and capital needs can support a stronger position. Lower Multiple, Lower Margin Below-median multiple · below-median EBITDA margin 1 names ProFrac Holding Corp. (ACDC) ProFrac Holding Corp. (ACDC) sits below both reference lines. Cost structure, asset use and the balance between owned supply and customer demand are the immediate operating levers.
- 1103 · THE AGENDA
Build or Buy: The Routes on the Table Ask for Different Capital and Pay Back on Different Timelines
Frames the build-versus-buy questions an owner or acquirer should resolve given the cohort data shown earlier.
The routes on the table here ask for different capital and pay back on different timelines, whether that means deepening contracts, extending delivered reach, moving downstream or comparing build with buy. These are framed as questions to resolve, grounded in the cohort data already shown, not as recommendations. Each path changes the earnings base a name can defend. So the choice between them should follow from where an asset already has an edge.
Everything on this page
03 · THE AGENDA Build or Buy: The Routes on the Table Ask for Different Capital and Pay Back on Different Timelines NeuraCap view · framed as the questions an owner or acquirer should resolve · observations, not recommendations Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. All content on this page is Directional — NeuraCap advisory judgment grounded in the cohort data shown earlier. It does not constitute investment advice. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 11 Deepen the Contract Base Shift revenue mix toward take-or-pay or multi-year offtake where customer demand supports it. Better tenor and counterparty quality can improve earnings durability. What changes the answer: Customer willingness to exchange flexibility for supply assurance changes the answer. Extend Delivered Reach Evaluate terminals, rail access and last-mile logistics against the cost of serving adjacent catchments. The objective is a better netback, not simply more tons. What changes the answer: A durable delivered cost advantage in an adjacent market changes the answer. Move Further Downstream Test beneficiation, separation, refining or formulated products where customer qualification and pricing support the capital. Downstream investment should improve product position and reduce exposure to undifferentiated tonnage. What changes the answer: A qualified customer base and defensible product specification change the answer. Compare Build with Buy Set greenfield permitting, construction and commissioning risk against available mines, plants or logistics assets. Use replacement cost and time to market as the decision frame. What changes the answer: An available asset with better timing or delivered economics changes the answer.
- 12SECTION 04
04
Section divider introducing the precedent-transactions section.
What buyers agreed to pay in this space reflects asset fit and strategic reach as much as size. The next page walks through recorded deals as case studies before the full list in the appendix.
Everything on this page
SECTION 04 04 PRECEDENT TRANSACTIONS What Buyers Agreed to Pay Reflects Asset Fit and Strategic Reach Precedent transactions span mineral supply, processing and adjacent service integration. 04 of 06 Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 12
- 1304 · DEAL CASE STUDIES
Precedent Transactions Span Supply, Processing and Vertical Integration
Walks through selected precedent transactions with disclosed terms, including Atlas Energy Solutions Inc.'s announced transaction for Hi-Crush Inc.
Precedent transactions in this space span mineral supply, processing and vertical integration into adjacent services. Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. agreed to an announced $450M transaction for Hi-Crush Inc., illustrating the scale attached to an in-segment combination. Deal multiples here sit on LTM financials at announcement, a different basis from the CY2027E public multiples used elsewhere in this report, so no direct spread is claimed. So we read these deals for what they say about strategic fit, not as a direct valuation bridge.
Everything on this page
04 · DEAL CASE STUDIES Precedent Transactions Span Supply, Processing and Vertical Integration 1 of 8 transactions with disclosed terms, told as case studies · multiples on LTM financials at announcement where disclosed · the complete list is in the appendix · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. 36 precedent record(s) carry data-quality flags (deal value unit unresolved; divestiture roles reassigned; duplicate precedent id); figures are shown as recorded in the filing. 23 recorded transactions with neither a disclosed value nor a multiple are omitted from the precedent list and the case studies (kept in the companion workbook). Deal multiples are LTM at announcement (Definitive, from filings); they are not directly comparable to the CY2027E public basis and no spread is claimed. "Why the deal happened" is a NeuraCap read of the recorded evidence. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 13 Feb-2024 $450M Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. (AESI) moved to combine with Hi-Crush Inc. in an announced in-segment transaction. EV / LTM revenue n/a EV / LTM EBITDA n/a WHY THE DEAL HAPPENED The transaction suggests a push to add mineral supply to an existing completions and pressure pumping services position. The strategic fit centres on scale and delivered reach within a shared customer chain. HOW THE TARGET WAS VALUED The disclosed transaction value was $450M. It benchmarks the scale buyers may attach to an integrated proppant and logistics position.
- 14SECTION 05
05
Section divider introducing the strategic-implications section.
Contract quality, logistics reach and downstream position should guide the operating and build-versus-buy choices ahead. The next page turns the report's findings into questions for owners, operators and capital allocators.
Everything on this page
SECTION 05 05 STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS Strengthen Delivered Economics Before Choosing the Capital Path Contract quality, logistics reach and downstream position should guide operating and build-versus-buy choices. 05 of 06 Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 14
- 1505 · STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS
Catchment Strength, the Contract Book and Capital Allocation Are Where the Valuation Gap Sits
Sets out what owners, operators and capital allocators should each prioritize given where the valuation gap sits.
Catchment strength, the contract book and capital allocation are where this report's valuation gap sits. Owners can focus the value case on delivered cost, retention and contract tenor; operators can prioritize netback before adding volume; capital allocators can weigh reserve extensions, logistics and downstream processing against contract quality and reach. These are directional views drawn from the analysis in this report, not recommendations to transact. So the next section turns to the full comparable set behind every figure shown.
Everything on this page
05 · STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS Catchment Strength, the Contract Book and Capital Allocation Are Where the Valuation Gap Sits NeuraCap view · the questions this data puts on the table for the next twelve months Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. This page is Directional — NeuraCap views drawn from the analysis in this report. Observations, not recommendations. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 15 FOR OWNERS Define the Earnings You Can Defend Focus the value case on delivered cost per ton, customer retention, contract tenor and the catchments where the asset has an enduring advantage. FOR OPERATORS Improve Netback Before Adding Volume Prioritise throughput, recovery, freight and last-mile choices that improve destination-level economics. Added tons matter when they strengthen contribution after delivery. FOR CAPITAL ALLOCATORS Fund Position, Not Capacity Alone Compare reserve extensions, logistics ownership and downstream processing on their ability to improve contract quality, customer reach and through-cycle cash generation.
- 16SECTION 06
06
06.
Section 06 of 06 — The Full Universe, Methodology and Sources. Comparables detail behind every figure in the body, the valuation basis, and where each underlying disclosure lives. Use this divider to reset the room before the section's pages; the progress dots show where the argument stands. 16
Everything on this page
SECTION 06 06 APPENDIX The Full Universe, Methodology and Sources Comparables detail behind every figure in the body, the valuation basis, and where each underlying disclosure lives. 06 of 06 Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 16
- 1706 · PUBLIC COMPARABLES (1 OF 1)
Public Comparables on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), Grouped by Valuation Tier
Lists the public comparables on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), grouped by valuation tier, covering rated and not-rated companies.
This appendix carries all rated companies alongside the names without an eligible EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) multiple, grouped by valuation tier against the 6.9x sector median. Every rated row here is also in the companion workbook, which carries the complete field set. This is the reference table behind the valuation pages earlier in the report. So a reader can check any comparable figure quoted upstream directly against this list.
Everything on this page
06 · PUBLIC COMPARABLES (1 OF 1) Public Comparables on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), Grouped by Valuation Tier Teal shading marks a EV/EBITDA above the sector median (6.9x); amber marks below · 4 rated companies; 6 not rated (no eligible EV/EBITDA) · tickers link to the underlying source · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. All 4 rated rows are in this appendix and in the companion workbook, which carries the complete field set. Names without an eligible multiple are listed in the companion workbook. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 17 Company Ticker Segment EV EV/EBITDA (CY2027E) Rev growth EBITDA margin Rule of 40 PREMIUM — ≥11.2x · median 23.1x · 1 companies MP Materials Corp. MP Bulk non-metallic mineral producers — borates, talc… $8.4B 23.1x 77% 7% 123 CORE — 6.2x–11.2x · median 6.9x · 2 companies Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. AESI Adjacent: completions and pressure pumping services $2.2B 7.2x 15% 20% 39 ProFrac Holding Corp. ACDC Adjacent: completions and pressure pumping services $2.2B 6.5x 11% 16% 26 DISCOUNT — <6.2x · median 5.5x · 1 companies ICL Group Ltd ICL Fertilizer minerals — potash and phosphate rock $9.5B 5.5x 3% 21% 24
- 1806 · PRECEDENT TRANSACTIONS (1 OF 1)
All Precedent Transactions with Disclosed Terms, Newest First
Lists all precedent transactions with disclosed terms, newest first, out of the full recorded set.
This appendix lists the transactions with disclosed terms in full, newest first, drawn from the broader recorded set discussed earlier. Deal multiples sit on LTM financials at announcement, a different basis from the CY2027E multiples used for public comparables. This is the complete reference behind the deal case studies shown in the body of the report. So a reader can trace any transaction referenced earlier back to this list.
Everything on this page
06 · PRECEDENT TRANSACTIONS (1 OF 1) All Precedent Transactions with Disclosed Terms, Newest First 8 transactions with disclosed terms in this tier (31 recorded) · multiples on LTM financials at announcement where disclosed · deal values link to the underlying filing · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. 36 precedent record(s) carry data-quality flags (deal value unit unresolved; divestiture roles reassigned; duplicate precedent id); figures are shown as recorded in the filing. 23 recorded transactions with neither a disclosed value nor a multiple are omitted from the precedent list and the case studies (kept in the companion workbook). Deal multiples are LTM at announcement (Definitive, from filings); they are not directly comparable to the CY2027E public basis and no spread is claimed. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 18 Date Transaction EV EV/LTM Rev EV/LTM EBITDA Why it matters Feb-2024 Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. → Hi-Crush Inc. $450M n/a n/a Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. (AESI) announced a transaction for Hi-Crush Inc. The pairing suggests added mineral supply within an existing completions and pressure pumping services position. Jun-2022 ProFrac Holding Corp. → West Texas subsidiaries of Signal Peak Silica n/a n/a 8.8x ProFrac Holding Corp. (ACDC) completed the acquisition of the West Texas subsidiaries of Signal Peak Silica at 8.8x EV / EBITDA. The transaction links a completions platform with upstream mineral supply. Jul-2020 n/a → MP Materials $1.0B 10.1x n/a The announced MP Materials transaction carried a $1.0B value and 10.1x EV / revenue. The valuation provides a reference for a model where future processing and supply-chain position matter alongside current earnings. Nov-2018 Undisclosed buyer → Tronox Limited $5.0B 2.7x n/a The completed Tronox Limited transaction carried a $5.0B value and 2.7x EV / revenue. It offers a scale reference for a whole-company mineral transaction. Jun-2018 Elementis plc → Mondo Minerals Holding B.V. n/a n/a 8.8x Elementis plc announced the acquisition of Mondo Minerals Holding B.V. at 8.8x EV / EBITDA. The combination suggests an expansion of mineral and product capabilities. Mar-2018 U.S. Silica → EP Minerals n/a n/a 12.5x U.S. Silica announced the acquisition of EP Minerals at 12.5x EV / EBITDA. The transaction benchmarks a mineral platform with differentiated processing and end-market exposure. Dec-2016 Evonik Industries AG → J.M. Huber Corporation’s Silica Business n/a 10.5x 10.5x Evonik Industries AG announced the acquisition of J.M. Huber Corporation’s Silica Business at 10.5x. The transaction suggests value in combining mineral feedstock with downstream processing capability. Dec-2016 Imerys S.A. → Kerneos n/a 8.9x 8.9x Imerys S.A. announced the acquisition of Kerneos at 8.9x. The pairing suggests a strategic fit around mineral processing and a broader product position.
- 1906 · METHODOLOGY
Sources, Assumptions and Data Quality
Sources, Assumptions and Data Quality.
Sources, Assumptions and Data Quality How this report was built, what was excluded, and where every underlying disclosure lives · as of 2026-09-28 Every figure in this report links to the record it was taken from. Where a figure has no link, the appendix names its source and the basis on which it was read. 19
Everything on this page
06 · METHODOLOGY Sources, Assumptions and Data Quality How this report was built, what was excluded, and where every underlying disclosure lives · as of 2026-09-28 Every figure in this report links to the record it was taken from. Where a figure has no link, the appendix names its source and the basis on which it was read. Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice 19 VALUATION BASIS Primary valuation basis: EV / EBITDA on CY2027E consensus (4 of 10 companies eligible; multiples failing the platform's plausibility gates are excluded, never plotted). Practitioners price this industry on EV / EBITDA rather than EV / Revenue; validated coverage supports the industry standard (6 of 10 companies), so this report follows it. EV / EBITDA on CY2027E is the lead convention: it is the sector-appropriate prior for Industrial Minerals and Mining and it clears the coverage gate with 4 of 10 companies (40%). P / E is carried as a cross-check. The set earns: 4 of 10 companies carry a meaningful forward EBITDA on CY2027E, so the profit multiple leads and a revenue multiple would understate what the market is pricing. DATA QUALITY & EXCLUSIONS 23 records were excluded or quarantined by the platform's validation gates (unit errors, implausible ratios, ineligible securities and classification failures); the full ledger ships in the companion tables and never feeds a statistic in this report. DEFINITIVE VS DIRECTIONAL Definitive content is disclosed or consensus data passed through stated arithmetic. Directional content — tier boundaries, situation cuts, "why it matters" commentary, the agenda pages — is NeuraCap analyst judgment and is labeled as such where it appears. WHAT THIS REPORT IS NOT This report characterises a sector. It does not recommend buying, selling or holding any security, and no statement in it should be read as investment advice or a price target. WHERE THE DATA LIVES 397 registered source documents stand behind the figures in this report. Metric hyperlinks throughout the deck open the specific filing or data record; by publisher: sec.gov (396) · home.treasury.gov (1). The companion workbook beside this deck carries the complete source index.
- 20
The Observed Premium Sits with Forecast Growth; Durable Value Still Needs Delivered Economics.
Closing page restates the report's central finding: the observed premium sits with forecast growth while durable value still needs delivered economics.
The observed premium sits with forecast growth; durable value still needs delivered economics. The companion tables beside this deck carry the full universe, the exclusion ledger and the complete source index for any figure a client wants to trace. That combination of the deck and its companion tables gives a complete, checkable view of this peer set. So this is the basis to bring into deeper diligence on any specific name.
Everything on this page
The Observed Premium Sits with Forecast Growth; Durable Value Still Needs Delivered Economics. NeuraCap AI — Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage September 2026 · Prepared by NeuraCap AI · Confidential Industrial Minerals and Mining Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 20
Sources and methodology
This report covers Industrial Minerals and Mining (Materials › Materials › Industrial Minerals and Mining) with market data and consensus estimates as of September 28, 2026. The company universe is the 10 listed companies whose core business is Industrial Minerals and Mining according to NeuraCap's industry classification of each company's reported business segments (a company is included only when this industry is central to what it does, not merely adjacent to it). Companies in the set: ProFrac Holding Corp. (ACDC), Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. (AESI), Compass Minerals International, Inc. (CMP), Critical Metals Corp. (CRML), ICL Group Ltd (ICL), MP Materials Corp. (MP), NioCorp Developments Ltd. (NB), NACCO Industries, Inc. (NC), Oil-Dri Corporation of America (ODC), Smart Sand, Inc. (SND). The market map groups them by business vertical — Bulk non-metallic mineral producers — borates, talc and kaolin: 4 companies (MP, CMP, CRML, NB); Adjacent: completions and pressure pumping services: 3 companies (AESI, ACDC, SND); Adjacent models: 3 companies (ICL, ODC, NC). 4 of the 10 companies carry a valid multiple on the primary valuation basis and form the rated set behind every cohort statistic; the others are shown but do not enter the statistics.
Scope and company universe
This report covers Industrial Minerals and Mining (Materials › Materials › Industrial Minerals and Mining) with market data and consensus estimates as of September 28, 2026. The company universe is the 10 listed companies whose core business is Industrial Minerals and Mining according to NeuraCap's industry classification of each company's reported business segments (a company is included only when this industry is central to what it does, not merely adjacent to it). Companies in the set: ProFrac Holding Corp. (ACDC), Atlas Energy Solutions Inc. (AESI), Compass Minerals International, Inc. (CMP), Critical Metals Corp. (CRML), ICL Group Ltd (ICL), MP Materials Corp. (MP), NioCorp Developments Ltd. (NB), NACCO Industries, Inc. (NC), Oil-Dri Corporation of America (ODC), Smart Sand, Inc. (SND). The market map groups them by business vertical — Bulk non-metallic mineral producers — borates, talc and kaolin: 4 companies (MP, CMP, CRML, NB); Adjacent: completions and pressure pumping services: 3 companies (AESI, ACDC, SND); Adjacent models: 3 companies (ICL, ODC, NC). 4 of the 10 companies carry a valid multiple on the primary valuation basis and form the rated set behind every cohort statistic; the others are shown but do not enter the statistics.
What was excluded and why
23 records failed a validation gate and never feed a statistic in this report (23 excluded from aggregate). Each exclusion, with its reason: ACDC — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · ACDC — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · ACDC — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · ACDC — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · AESI — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · AESI — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · AESI — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · AESI — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · CMP — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · CRML — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · CRML — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · CRML — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · CRML — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · MP — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · MP — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · NB — EBITDA is non-positive; EV/EBITDA is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · NB — EBITDA is non-positive; EV/EBITDA is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · NB — EBITDA is non-positive; EV/EBITDA is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · NB — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · NB — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · NB — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · NB — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · SND — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate)
Primary valuation basis and how it was chosen
Primary valuation basis: EV / EBITDA on CY2027E consensus (4 of 10 companies eligible; multiples failing the platform's plausibility gates are excluded, never plotted). Practitioners price this industry on EV / EBITDA rather than EV / Revenue; validated coverage supports the industry standard (6 of 10 companies), so this report follows it. EV / EBITDA on CY2027E is the lead convention: it is the sector-appropriate prior for Industrial Minerals and Mining and it clears the coverage gate with 4 of 10 companies (40%). P / E is carried as a cross-check. The set earns: 4 of 10 companies carry a meaningful forward EBITDA on CY2027E, so the profit multiple leads and a revenue multiple would understate what the market is pricing. The basis is selected in two steps: the industry's customary valuation conventions set the order of preference, and each convention is then tested for coverage — the share of companies with a valid, plausibility-checked multiple on the chosen period. A convention is used only when enough companies carry it; the best-covered convention is used, and disclosed, when none clears the threshold. Coverage measured for this report — EV / EBITDA: 4 of 10 companies; EV / rEVenue: 8 of 10 companies; P/E: 3 of 10 companies. 1 company shows a non-meaningful EV / EBITDA denominator and is excluded from that statistic. 5 companies show a non-meaningful P / E denominator and are excluded from that statistic.
How the multiples and statistics are computed
Enterprise value (EV) is market capitalisation at the as-of date plus total debt minus cash and equivalents from the latest reported balance sheet, reconciled against the platform's stored value and disclosed where the two differ. Forward multiples divide EV (or the share price for P/E) by the consensus estimate for the stated calendar period; trailing multiples use the last twelve months of reported figures from SEC filings. A multiple with a negative or immaterial denominator is treated as not meaningful and excluded from every statistic. Cohort statistics are medians and quartiles over the rated set only; a group median with fewer than three observations is shown as the single company's figure and labelled as such. Valuation tiers cut the rated set at its quartiles (tiers cut at the rated set's quartiles: Premium ≥11.2x, Core 6.2x–11.2x, Discount <6.2x — NeuraCap groupings). Revenue growth compares consecutive calendar-year consensus revenue; EBITDA margin divides consensus EBITDA by consensus revenue for the same period. Figures shown in this report and the calculation behind each: 6.9x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) (4 rated companies) · 23.1x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) within Premium tier (n=1) · 6.9x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) within Core tier (n=2) · 5.5x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) within Discount tier (n=1) · 31% = median Rule of 40 score (revenue growth + EBITDA margin) (n=4)
Precedent transactions: what is in the record and why
The precedent record holds the M&A transactions in Industrial Minerals and Mining recorded from SEC filings (8-K announcements and the documents they reference), newest first, with each value and multiple linked to the exact passage in the filing that states it. 31 transactions were recorded for this industry; 8 are shown. 23 recorded transactions with neither a disclosed value nor a multiple are omitted because they say nothing about price; they remain in the companion workbook. Deal multiples are enterprise value over the target's last-twelve-month revenue or EBITDA at announcement, as disclosed; they are not restated to the public basis and no spread to the public multiples is claimed. Before a transaction reaches the record it passes a screen for mirrored or duplicate filings of the same deal, for divestitures where the filer is the seller rather than the buyer, for carve-outs recorded under the parent's name, and for values whose citation describes something other than the price paid (a debt raise, a termination fee); such records are corrected or excluded and the correction is noted. Data-quality notes on this record: 14 × deal value unit unresolved; 17 × no evidence record; 1 × duplicate precedent id; 4 × divestiture roles reassigned. Case studies lead with the 1 richest stories — disclosed value, a readable multiple, newest first.
Sources
Company financials and transaction terms come from the companies' own SEC filings on EDGAR (10-K, 10-Q and 8-K documents), linked from each figure in the report. Forward figures are analyst consensus estimates for the calendar periods shown. Share prices and market capitalisations are market data as of September 28, 2026. Treasury yields are published by the U.S. Department of the Treasury. 401 source documents stand behind this report; by publisher domain: sec.gov, home.treasury.gov (1). Every figure on every page is traceable to one of these records; nothing in the report is derived from outside data.
Interpretation and important notice
Tier labels, situation maps, the agenda and the implications pages are NeuraCap analytical views drawn from the recorded evidence and are labelled as such. The report is informational: it is not investment advice, not a recommendation to buy or sell any security, not an opinion of value and not an offer of any kind. Readers should perform their own diligence before acting on anything described here.
Sources linked in the report
- MP Materials (MP) (sec.gov)
- Compass Minerals (CMP) (sec.gov)
- NioCorp (NB) (sec.gov)
- Atlas Energy (AESI) (sec.gov)
- ProFrac Holding (ACDC) (sec.gov)
- Smart Sand (SND) (sec.gov)
- Oil-Dri (ODC) (sec.gov)
- NACCO Industries (NC) (sec.gov)
- $450M (sec.gov)
- n/a (sec.gov)
- $1.0B (sec.gov)
- $5.0B (sec.gov)
- 10.5x (sec.gov)
- sec.gov (396) (sec.gov)
- home.treasury.gov (1) (home.treasury.gov)
This report is published for information only. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security, an offer or solicitation, an appraisal or a fairness opinion, and no fiduciary relationship is created by reading it. Multiples that fail NeuraCap’s plausibility gates are excluded and never plotted. See the full methodology and the disclaimer.
More coverage in Materials
- M&A Update · 28 September 2026Materials Distribution and Sourcing M&A update, 14–28 September 2026
- Sector Outlook · 28 September 2026Materials Distribution and Sourcing Sector Outlook — September 2026
- M&A Update · 28 September 2026Mining Exploration and Royalties M&A update, 14–28 September 2026
- Sector Outlook · 28 September 2026Mining Exploration and Royalties Sector Outlook — September 2026
Want this analysis for a company in Industrial Minerals and Mining?
Company valuation reports run the same method against a single business — public or private.
