Steel Sector Outlook — September 2026
A read of eleven listed steelmakers on EV/EBITDA (CY2027E): where the price band sits, what separates the top and bottom of the range, and what buyers agreed to pay across nine recorded transactions. Built for owners, acquirers and boards assessing where a steel business sits in this pattern.
For information only. Not an appraisal or a fairness opinion.
What moved since: Steel M&A update, 14–28 September 2026
Key figures
- Sector median EV/EBITDA
- 5.7x
- CY2027E, 10 of 11 rated
- Top-of-range multiple
- 7.4x
- Top 3 of 10 rated names
- Bottom-of-range multiple
- 4.3x
- Bottom 3 of 10 rated names
- Largest disclosed deal value
- $9.2B
- Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. / United States Steel Corporation
Read the report
1 / 22 · Steel: Valuation Gaps Across This Set Are Not Tracking Current Operating Performance
Executive summary
Eleven listed steelmakers sit in one business-model group, yet price spreads wide inside it: the median is 5.7x EV/EBITDA (CY2027E) across ten rated names. The higher-priced half is not the faster-growing half — margin splits track price (4.5x above a 17% line vs 6.0x below), while growth runs the other way. Recorded deals show buyers paying up to 13.5x, including Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.'s $9.2B agreement for United States Steel Corporation. The premium tracks earnings durability, not current operating performance.
Key findings
- Higher prices in this set track earnings durability, not growth or margin alone
- The faster-growing half of rated names prices below the slower-growing half
- Segment classification doesn't separate this set — 100% sit in one group
- Recorded deal multiples span a wide range, up to 13.5x on disclosed terms
What each page shows
The analyst’s walkthrough of the deck, page by page.
- 01MATERIALS › MATERIALS › STEEL
Steel: Valuation Gaps Across This Set Are Not Tracking Current Operating Performance
Cover slide framing the report's finding that valuation gaps across the steel set are not tracking current operating performance.
We open with the finding that carries this deck: valuation gaps across this steel set are not tracking current operating performance. Everything that follows traces where that gap sits and what it means for an owner or acquirer.
Everything on this page
MATERIALS › MATERIALS › STEEL Steel: Valuation Gaps Across This Set Are Not Tracking Current Operating Performance A read of eleven listed steelmakers, what forward EBITDA separates inside the set, and what buyers agreed to pay in the recorded transactions. September 2026 · Prepared by NeuraCap AI · Confidential Market data as of 2026-09-28 · primary valuation basis EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 1
- 02CONTENTS
What This Report Covers
Contents page listing the report's five sections plus appendix.
This report runs five sections plus an appendix, starting with the bottom line so a reader who stops early still leaves with the full story. We built it this way because the headline finding matters more than the sequence used to reach it. From here we move through the market landscape, valuation and situations, precedent transactions, and strategic implications.
Everything on this page
CONTENTS What This Report Covers 01 The Bottom Line The Bottom Line: Price and Performance Sit Apart in Steel 02 The Landscape One Producer Group Holds the Whole Steel Screen 03 Valuation & Situations The Top and the Bottom of the CY2027E Range 04 Precedent Transactions What Buyers Agreed to Pay Across Nine Recorded Steel Transactions 05 Strategic Implications What the Gap Between the Two Ends Means for an Operator 06 Appendix Comparables Detail, Methodology, Sources and Assumptions Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 2
- 0301 · THE BOTTOM LINE
Steel Is Priced as One Field of Multi-Route Producers, and the Higher-Priced Half Is Not the Faster-Growing Half
Summary page stating that steel prices as one group of multi-route producers and the higher-priced half is not the faster-growing half.
This is the full story on one page: the set prices as one field of multi-route producers on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), with a median of 5.7x across ten of eleven companies carrying an estimate. The higher-priced half of this set is not the faster-growing half — the premium sits with something other than growth. That gap is what the rest of this report unpacks, section by section, so we can point to where it comes from.
Everything on this page
01 · THE BOTTOM LINE Steel Is Priced as One Field of Multi-Route Producers, and the Higher-Priced Half Is Not the Faster-Growing Half The full story on one page · figures on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), market data as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Primary valuation basis: EV / EBITDA on CY2027E consensus (10 of 11 companies eligible; multiples failing the platform's plausibility gates are excluded, never plotted). Qualitative characterisations are NeuraCap views. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 3 1 The Price Gaps Here Open Inside One Business Model 11 of the 11 companies classify as diversified multi-route steel producers, 100% of the set, so the price gaps here sit inside one business model rather than between different ones. The middle of the range is 5.7x forward EBITDA on CY2027E, with 10 of the 11 companies carrying an estimate. 2 The Faster-Growing Half Carries the Lower Price Split at 4% revenue growth, the five faster-growing names sit at 5.3x and the five slower-growing names at 6.5x on CY2027E EBITDA. The gap runs against the usual direction, and a forward multiple already credits forecast growth, so the premium at the top is sitting with something other than the growth line. 3 The Price Gap Is Wider than the Performance Gap The three names at the top of the range sit at 7.4x on CY2027E EBITDA against 4.3x for the three at the bottom. The operating numbers underneath do not spread nearly as far, so the wider valuation gap is associated with views on how durable the earnings are judged to be rather than with current performance. 4 What Buyers Agreed to Pay Spans a Wide Band Across the nine recorded transactions, disclosed multiples run as high as 13.5x on an announced stainless long products carve-out. Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. agreed $9.2B for United States Steel Corporation, the largest disclosed value among the nine, with smaller cross-border carve-outs at the other end of the band. 5.7x Sector median EV/EBITDA CY2027E consensus · 10 rated of 11 companies 7.4x Premium end EV/EBITDA vs 4.3x at the discount end top quartile (n=3) against bottom quartile (n=3) on EV/EBITDA — the spread the report explains 21 Transactions with disclosed terms 58 recorded in this tier · 1 told as case studies, the full list in the appendix
- 04SECTION 02
02
Section divider introducing the market landscape: one producer group, eleven companies, one wide price band.
This section opens the market map: eleven companies, one diversified multi-route classification, and a price band that still spreads wide inside it. We use this page to reset before walking through where each name sits.
Everything on this page
SECTION 02 02 THE LANDSCAPE One Producer Group Holds the Whole Steel Screen Eleven companies, a single diversified multi-route classification, and a wide price band inside it. 02 of 06 Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 4
- 0502 · MARKET MAP
This Set Sits in One Group, and the Price Still Spreads Wide Inside It
Chart grouping the eleven approved companies by business segment with median EV/EBITDA per group.
All of this set falls into a single diversified multi-route classification — 100% of the eleven companies — yet the price still spreads wide inside that one group. That tells us segment labels alone are not doing the separating work here. The next pages dig into what is.
Everything on this page
02 · MARKET MAP This Set Sits in One Group, and the Price Still Spreads Wide Inside It 11 approved companies grouped by business segment · median EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) per group · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Segment grouping follows the platform's classification; group medians on rated names only. "Why it matters" lines are NeuraCap views. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 5 DIVERSIFIED MULTI-ROUTE STEEL PRODUCERS 11 cos median 5.7x ArcelorMittal S.A. (MT) Nucor (NUE) Steel Dynamics (STLD) POSCO Holdings (PKX) Ternium S.A. (TX) Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) Gerdau S.A. (GGB) Commercial Metals (CMC) Companhia (SID) Algoma Steel Group (ASTL) Metallus (MTUS) The set classifies into a single group of 11 producers, so what separates prices here is cost curve position, downstream mix and contract book rather than category.
- 0602 · LANDSCAPE
The Segment Label Does Little to Separate These Names; Operating Position Sits with the Price Gap
Segment view of the approved universe showing EV/EBITDA medians on rated names by segment.
The segment label does little to separate these names — operating position, not classification, is where the price gap sits. We walk through what each group does and why it matters, then point to the full company-level detail in the appendix for anyone who wants to trace a specific name.
Everything on this page
02 · LANDSCAPE The Segment Label Does Little to Separate These Names; Operating Position Sits with the Price Gap Segment view of the approved universe · EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) medians on rated names · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. "What they do / why it matters" is a NeuraCap view. Full company-level detail in the appendix and companion tables. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 6 Segment n Share of universe Median EV/EBITDA Names to know What they do — and why it matters Diversified multi-route steel producers 11 100% 5.7x ArcelorMittal S.A. (MT) · Nucor Corporation (NUE) · +9 more One group, eleven operators. These producers run blast furnace–BOF and electric arc furnace routes across long products, coated and special bar quality mix. With 10 of the 11 companies carrying a CY2027E EBITDA estimate, this group is the pricing reference for any steel asset discussion, and the spread inside it is where the argument actually happens.
- 07SECTION 03
03
Section divider introducing the top and bottom of the CY2027E valuation range.
This section ranks the ten rated names from top to bottom of the CY2027E range. Ten of the eleven companies carry a CY2027E EBITDA estimate, and here is how they stack up.
Everything on this page
SECTION 03 03 VALUATION & SITUATIONS The Top and the Bottom of the CY2027E Range 10 of the 11 companies carry a CY2027E EBITDA estimate; here is how the 10 rated names rank. 03 of 06 Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 7
- 0803 · PUBLIC MARKET VALUATION
The Top of the Range Holds the Steadier Earners, the Bottom Holds the Faster Growers
Ranked chart of EV/EBITDA (CY2027E) across all ten rated companies against a sector median of 5.7x.
Across all ten rated companies, sorted descending on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), the sector median sits at 5.7x. The top of the range holds the steadier earners; the bottom holds the faster growers. That split is the pattern this whole report is built around, so it is worth holding in mind as we move into what drives it.
Everything on this page
03 · PUBLIC MARKET VALUATION The Top of the Range Holds the Steadier Earners, the Bottom Holds the Faster Growers EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) · all 10 rated companies, sorted descending · sector median 5.7x · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Primary valuation basis: EV / EBITDA on CY2027E consensus (10 of 11 companies eligible; multiples failing the platform's plausibility gates are excluded, never plotted). Tier zones are NeuraCap groupings cut at the rated set's quartiles; every multiple quoted on this page is a median on the same EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) basis. Panel commentary is a NeuraCap view. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 8 PREMIUM · median 7.4x CORE · median 5.7x DISCOUNT · median 4.3x Sector median 5.7x WHAT SEPARATES THE TWO ENDS The top holds 7.4x. The three names at the premium end sit at 7.4x on CY2027E EBITDA. Two of them post margins of 21% and 20% on revenue growth of 1% and 2%, so the price at the top of the range sits alongside steady profitability rather than volume expansion. The bottom holds 4.3x. The three names at the discount end sit at 4.3x on the same lens. Companhia Siderúrgica Nacional (SID) carries a 27% margin and still prices at the bottom of the range, which is why profitability on its own is not explaining the ranking on this page. Forward pricing already credits growth. The lens is CY2027E EBITDA, so a forecast of better shipments and better metal spread is already inside the number. A premium that survives that test points to earnings the market expects to hold through the cycle, and that is what the underwriting conversation turns on.
- 0903 · VALUATION DRIVERS
Profitability Separates the Two Ends: Names Above the 17% Margin Line Carry 4.5x Against 6.0x Below It
Cohort comparison showing median EV/EBITDA by revenue-growth and EBITDA-margin splits.
Split at a 17% margin line, names above it carry 4.5x on CY2027E EBITDA against 6.0x for names below it — margin is moving with price in the direction we'd expect. Growth is not: the faster-growing cohort prices lower than the slower-growing cohort. That combination is an association in the data, not a claim about cause, but it is a clear signal of where the premium is and is not attaching.
Everything on this page
03 · VALUATION DRIVERS Profitability Separates the Two Ends: Names Above the 17% Margin Line Carry 4.5x Against 6.0x Below It Median EV / EBITDA (CY2027E) by revenue-growth cohort and by EBITDA-margin cohort (each split at its covered median) · rated names with estimates · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Cohort medians on rated names with the required estimates (faster n=5; slower n=5; higher-margin n=5; lower-margin n=5). Driver readings are NeuraCap views on the supplied data — association, not causation. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 9 EV/EBITDA, median per cohort · growth split at 4% · EBITDA-margin split at 17% The Growth Split Runs Backwards Split at 4% revenue growth, the five faster-growing names sit at 5.3x and the five slower-growing names at 6.5x on CY2027E EBITDA. Both halves sit in the same producer group, so the gap is inside one business model rather than between two different ones. High Margin Shows up at Both Ends The margin line across the set runs at 17%. Companhia Siderúrgica Nacional (SID) at 27% and Ternium S.A. (TX) at 19% both price in the discount tier, while Nucor Corporation (NUE) at 20% prices in the premium tier, so margin on its own is not separating the field either. Earnings Dispersion Is the Live Variable Inside one producer group the visible differences are contract versus spot share of the order book, coated and special bar quality mix, and conversion cost per tonne. These are the items associated with EBITDA per tonne holding when metal spread moves, and they are what a buyer tests behind any multiple. Region Travels with the Price The three names at the bottom of the range are Latin American producers; the three at the top are North American. Freight economics, import competition and trade remedy regimes make those two positions different underwriting problems, on a set of 10 rated names rather than a census.
- 1003 · SITUATION MAP
Where the Money Sits: Price Against Growth for the 10 Rated Names
Quadrant map cutting the ten rated names on EV/EBITDA versus the sector median and revenue growth versus the covered median.
Cutting on EV / EBITDA against the 5.7x sector median and revenue growth against the 4% covered median gives four situations rather than one spectrum. This page characterises where each name sits; it is not a recommendation to buy or sell any of them. It is the map we use to frame the conversation that follows.
Everything on this page
03 · SITUATION MAP Where the Money Sits: Price Against Growth for the 10 Rated Names Cut on EV / EBITDA vs the sector median (5.7x) (rows) and revenue growth vs the covered median (4%) (columns) · observations, not recommendations Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Situation boundaries are the cohort's own medians (Directional, NeuraCap view). This page characterises situations; it does not recommend buying or selling any security. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 10 Priced up and Growing Above-median multiple · above-median revenue growth 2 names ArcelorMittal S.A. (MT) · Commercial Metals Company (CMC) ArcelorMittal S.A. (MT) and Commercial Metals Company (CMC) sit above the middle of the range on price and above it on revenue growth. With two names here, read it as a position to defend rather than a pattern — mix and contract book are what a buyer would test behind it. Priced up on Steady Earnings Above-median multiple · below-median revenue growth 3 names Nucor Corporation (NUE) · Steel Dynamics, Inc. (STLD) · Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (CLF) Nucor Corporation (NUE), Steel Dynamics, Inc. (STLD) and Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (CLF) price above the middle with growth below it. The premium on CY2027E EBITDA sits alongside steady margin and scale rather than volume expansion, and that is the position the top of the range is holding. Growing, Priced Below Below-median multiple · above-median revenue growth 3 names Ternium S.A. (TX) · Companhia Siderúrgica Nacional (SID) · Metallus Inc. (MTUS) Ternium S.A. (TX), Companhia Siderúrgica Nacional (SID) and Metallus Inc. (MTUS) grow faster than the middle and price below it. The question for an owner in this corner is which part of the earnings stream the market is treating as temporary — spread, region or mix — because that is where the operating work goes. Below on Both Below-median multiple · below-median revenue growth 2 names POSCO Holdings Inc. (PKX) · Gerdau S.A. (GGB) POSCO Holdings Inc. (PKX) and Gerdau S.A. (GGB) sit below the middle on both measures. On two names the read is narrow, and the levers that show up in this set are cost curve position and value-added share rather than tonnes alone.
- 1103 · GROWTH VS PROFITABILITY
Clearing Both the Growth and Margin Bars Is Sitting with the Lower Price
Quadrant chart of revenue growth versus EBITDA margin at the covered medians, with median EV/EBITDA per quadrant.
Cut at 4% growth and 17% margin, the names that clear both bars sit with the lower price, not the higher one. That is the clearest version of the pattern in this deck: operating strength on both dimensions is not commanding the premium in this set. Whether that gap is durable or temporary is the question the rest of the report puts on the table.
Everything on this page
03 · GROWTH VS PROFITABILITY Clearing Both the Growth and Margin Bars Is Sitting with the Lower Price Revenue growth (CY2027E, x-axis) vs EBITDA margin (CY2027E, y-axis) · 10 companies with both estimates · cuts at the covered medians (4% growth, 17% margin) · median EV/EBITDA per quadrant · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. Quadrant cuts are the covered set's medians. Quadrant medians on names with a meaningful EV/EBITDA (balanced n=2; margin-only n=3; growth-only n=3; neither n=2). Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 11 2% 4% 6% 10% 15% 20% 25% MARGIN ONLY median 7.4x BALANCED median 4.0x NEITHER median 5.6x GROWTH ONLY median 6.0x STLD NUE GGB CLF PKX SID CMC TX MT MTUS x: revenue growth (CY2027E) · y: EBITDA margin (CY2027E) HOW TO READ THIS The chart splits the 10 rated names on revenue growth and at a 17% EBITDA margin. On the two names clearing both bars — Ternium S.A. (TX) and Companhia Siderúrgica Nacional (SID) — the middle price is 4.0x, below the three names clearing growth only at 6.0x and the two clearing neither at 5.6x. Read it as an observation on a small set, not a rule: with two names in that corner, the diligence question is why the market treats those earnings as temporary. Rule of 40 (revenue growth + EBITDA margin ≥ 40%): 0 of 10 names clear it.
- 1203 · THE AGENDA
Four Operating Choices That Track Alongside Where a Steel Business Prices
Framework of four operating questions an owner or acquirer should resolve, drawn from the cohort data.
We frame four operating choices that track alongside where a steel business prices in this set: hardening the earnings stream, moving down the cost curve, weighing build versus buy on tonnes, and timing capital against the reline calendar. These are observations grounded in the cohort data, not recommendations. Each is a lever an operator can pull well before the market re-rates the business.
Everything on this page
03 · THE AGENDA Four Operating Choices That Track Alongside Where a Steel Business Prices NeuraCap view · framed as the questions an owner or acquirer should resolve · observations, not recommendations Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. All content on this page is Directional — NeuraCap advisory judgment grounded in the cohort data shown earlier. It does not constitute investment advice. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 12 Harden the Earnings Stream The top of the range in this set holds names with steady margin through slower growth. Contract share of the order book, coated and special bar quality mix, and a freight-defended service radius are the levers that make EBITDA per tonne less dependent on spot spread. What changes the answer: A quarter where metal spread falls and EBITDA per tonne holds. Move Down the Cost Curve Conversion cost per tonne and raw material position separate operators inside one business model. Captive or contracted scrap, pig iron, HBI and DRI supply reduce dependence on merchant prices when the cycle turns against you. What changes the answer: Conversion cost per tonne moving against the regional benchmark. Argue Build Versus Buy on Tonnes Strategic buyers in this record added capacity in regions they already served instead of building it. The same arithmetic runs in reverse for an owner: what a new line would cost, and how long permitting, power and interconnection would take, against the price of installed tonnes. What changes the answer: A permitted brownfield site with power in place coming available. Time Capital Against the Reline Calendar Reline and major maintenance timing, decarbonisation spend and available incentives sit behind how the market reads a mill's next five years. Funding capacity is what separates the moat reading from the overhang reading, and it is decided well before the spend lands. What changes the answer: A reline or conversion decision entering the next capital plan.
- 13SECTION 04
04
Section divider introducing what buyers agreed to pay across nine recorded steel transactions.
This section moves from public pricing to what buyers actually agreed to pay: nine transactions recorded as announced. We use these to check what the deal market has been willing to fund.
Everything on this page
SECTION 04 04 PRECEDENT TRANSACTIONS What Buyers Agreed to Pay Across Nine Recorded Steel Transactions Nine transactions from May-2018 to Oct-2025, all recorded as announced. 04 of 06 Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 13
- 1404 · DEAL CASE STUDIES
Consolidation, Carve-Outs and Supply: What Steel Buyers Agreed to Pay
Case studies drawn from transactions with disclosed terms, showing multiples on LTM financials at announcement.
The recorded deals span consolidation, carve-outs and supply arrangements, with disclosed multiples running as high as 13.5x on an announced stainless long products carve-out. The largest disclosed value in the set is Cleveland-Cliffs Inc.'s $9.2B agreement for United States Steel Corporation. These multiples sit on LTM financials at announcement, a different basis from the CY2027E public multiples earlier in the deck, so we do not claim a spread between the two — the complete list sits in the appendix for anyone tracing a specific deal.
Everything on this page
04 · DEAL CASE STUDIES Consolidation, Carve-Outs and Supply: What Steel Buyers Agreed to Pay 1 of 21 transactions with disclosed terms, told as case studies · multiples on LTM financials at announcement where disclosed · the complete list is in the appendix · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. 50 precedent record(s) carry data-quality flags (deal value unit unresolved; divestiture roles reassigned; duplicate precedent id); figures are shown as recorded in the filing. 37 recorded transactions with neither a disclosed value nor a multiple are omitted from the precedent list and the case studies (kept in the companion workbook). Deal multiples are LTM at announcement (Definitive, from filings); they are not directly comparable to the CY2027E public basis and no spread is claimed. "Why the deal happened" is a NeuraCap read of the recorded evidence. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 14 Jul-2022 $2.2B ArcelorMittal acquires Companhia Siderúrgica do Pecém EV / LTM revenue n/a EV / LTM EBITDA n/a WHY THE DEAL HAPPENED A producer buying a producer in a region it already serves: the transaction suggests adding installed capacity where the alternative was the cost and timeline of a new line, including permits, power and ramp. It is one of the larger disclosed values in this record, consistent with a whole-company purchase rather than an asset package. HOW THE TARGET WAS VALUED The announced enterprise value is $2.2B, which places it in the whole-company bracket of this record rather than the small carve-out bracket. Where multiples are disclosed in the same record, steel purchases sit from 4.6x through 8.0x, with one specialty carve-out priced above that band.
- 15SECTION 05
05
Section divider introducing what the valuation gap means for an operator.
This section turns the price gap into operating moves. We look at what sits behind the spread between the top and bottom of this range and what that means for an operator's next steps.
Everything on this page
SECTION 05 05 STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS What the Gap Between the Two Ends Means for an Operator Operating moves that sit behind the spread between the two ends. 05 of 06 Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 15
- 1605 · STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS
Durability of Earnings Is What the Top of This Range Sits Alongside
NeuraCap view laying out the questions the data puts on the table for owners, buyers and boards.
Durability of earnings is what the top of this range sits alongside, and that reading carries different implications depending on where you sit. For owners, it points to the contract book and mix work that holds EBITDA per tonne. For buyers, it flags that growth is available below the middle of the range, and for boards, it frames the peer set as operators running the same melt routes. These are observations built on the analysis in this report, not recommendations.
Everything on this page
05 · STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS Durability of Earnings Is What the Top of This Range Sits Alongside NeuraCap view · the questions this data puts on the table for the next twelve months Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. This page is Directional — NeuraCap views drawn from the analysis in this report. Observations, not recommendations. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 16 FOR OWNERS Steadiness Is Showing up in the Price On CY2027E EBITDA the top of the range holds names with steady margin and modest growth. If your earnings swing with spot spread, the operating work is contract book, coated and special bar quality mix, and cost per tonne — the items that hold EBITDA per tonne when the spread moves. FOR BUYERS Growth Is Available Below the Middle Three of the 10 rated names grow faster than the middle of the set and price below it. Whether that gap reflects regional exposure, mix or a view on mid-cycle spread is the diligence question, and the answer sits in the order book and the cost curve rather than in the screen. FOR BOARDS Your Peer Set Runs the Same Routes The 10 rated names sit in the same diversified multi-route producer group, so the comparison a board faces is with operators running the same melt routes and product families. Position inside that group — cost curve, mix, contract share — is what the price differences here sit alongside.
- 17SECTION 06
06
Section divider introducing the full comparables universe, methodology and sources.
This closing section carries the comparables detail behind every figure in the body, the valuation basis used throughout, and where each underlying disclosure sits. We use it as the reference section for anyone who wants to trace a specific number back to its source.
Everything on this page
SECTION 06 06 APPENDIX The Full Universe, Methodology and Sources Comparables detail behind every figure in the body, the valuation basis, and where each underlying disclosure lives. 06 of 06 Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 17
- 1806 · PUBLIC COMPARABLES (1 OF 1)
Public Comparables on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), Grouped by Valuation Tier
Full comparables table of ten rated companies on EV/EBITDA (CY2027E), shaded above and below the sector median.
This table carries all ten rated companies on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), shaded above and below the 5.7x sector median, plus the one name in this set without an eligible multiple. It is the company-level detail behind every group and quadrant chart earlier in the deck. Anyone checking a specific name against the pattern we described can find it here.
Everything on this page
06 · PUBLIC COMPARABLES (1 OF 1) Public Comparables on EV / EBITDA (CY2027E), Grouped by Valuation Tier Teal shading marks a EV/EBITDA above the sector median (5.7x); amber marks below · 10 rated companies; 1 not rated (no eligible EV/EBITDA) · tickers link to the underlying source · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. All 10 rated rows are in this appendix and in the companion workbook, which carries the complete field set. Names without an eligible multiple are listed in the companion workbook. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 18 Company Ticker Segment EV EV/EBITDA (CY2027E) Rev growth EBITDA margin Rule of 40 PREMIUM — ≥6.7x · median 7.4x · 3 companies Steel Dynamics, Inc. STLD Diversified multi-route steel producers $37.4B 7.6x 1% 21% 21 Nucor Corporation NUE Diversified multi-route steel producers $61.7B 7.4x 2% 20% 22 Commercial Metals Company CMC Diversified multi-route steel producers $10.4B 6.7x 5% 15% 20 CORE — 4.5x–6.7x · median 5.7x · 4 companies Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. CLF Diversified multi-route steel producers $14.9B 6.5x 3% 10% 13 ArcelorMittal S.A. MT Diversified multi-route steel producers $65.2B 6.0x 5% 15% 21 Metallus Inc. MTUS Diversified multi-route steel producers $693M 5.3x 8% 9% 17 POSCO Holdings Inc. PKX Diversified multi-route steel producers $31.8B 4.7x 4% 11% 15 DISCOUNT — <4.5x · median 4.3x · 3 companies Gerdau S.A. GGB Diversified multi-route steel producers $11.5B 4.5x 3% 18% 21 Ternium S.A. TX Diversified multi-route steel producers $15.3B 4.3x 5% 19% 25 Companhia Siderúrgica Nacional SID Diversified multi-route steel producers $9.3B 3.8x 4% 27% 31
- 1906 · PRECEDENT TRANSACTIONS (1 OF 2)
All Precedent Transactions with Disclosed Terms, Newest First
First page of the precedent transaction list, sorted newest first, showing multiples on LTM financials at announcement.
This is the first page of the transactions carrying disclosed terms, sorted newest first, with multiples on LTM financials at announcement where disclosed. These figures back the case studies and the deal-market read earlier in the deck. The remaining transactions continue on the following page.
Everything on this page
06 · PRECEDENT TRANSACTIONS (1 OF 2) All Precedent Transactions with Disclosed Terms, Newest First 21 transactions with disclosed terms in this tier (58 recorded) · multiples on LTM financials at announcement where disclosed · deal values link to the underlying filing · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. 50 precedent record(s) carry data-quality flags (deal value unit unresolved; divestiture roles reassigned; duplicate precedent id); figures are shown as recorded in the filing. 37 recorded transactions with neither a disclosed value nor a multiple are omitted from the precedent list and the case studies (kept in the companion workbook). Deal multiples are LTM at announcement (Definitive, from filings); they are not directly comparable to the CY2027E public basis and no spread is claimed. 18 of 21 transactions shown; the rest are in the companion workbook. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 19 Date Transaction EV EV/LTM Rev EV/LTM EBITDA Why it matters Oct-2025 Ryerson Holding Corporation → Olympic Steel, Inc. $619M n/a n/a Ryerson Holding Corporation announced the purchase of Olympic Steel, Inc. in Oct-2025 at $619M. Both sit downstream of the mills, and the transaction suggests scale in processing and distribution, where the earnings stream is steadier than at the melt shop. Nov-2024 Intelcia Group S.A → Aços Laminados do Pará S.A. n/a n/a 8.0x Intelcia Group S.A announced the purchase of Aços Laminados do Pará S.A. in Nov-2024 at 8.0x EBITDA. That sits above the range the 10 rated names occupy today on CY2027E EBITDA, which is the kind of level long products assets attract when supply position is part of… Aug-2023 Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. → United States Steel Corporation $9.2B n/a n/a Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. announced an agreement for United States Steel Corporation in Aug-2023 at $9.2B, the largest disclosed value among the nine transactions here. Domestic consolidation of that size runs into antitrust review, which is part of why buyers in this… Jul-2022 ArcelorMittal → Companhia Siderúrgica do Pecém $2.2B n/a n/a ArcelorMittal announced the purchase of Companhia Siderúrgica do Pecém in Jul-2022 at $2.2B. Buying installed capacity in a market a producer already serves is the standard alternative to a greenfield or brownfield line, and it is the comparison strategic acquirers… Jul-2022 Health Advocate → Outokumpu Oyj (Stainless Steel Long Products Business) n/a n/a 13.5x Health Advocate announced the purchase of the Outokumpu Oyj (Stainless Steel Long Products Business) in Jul-2022 at 13.5x EBITDA. Stainless long products carry a different mix and a slower-to-replicate customer qualification profile than commodity tonnes, and the… Nov-2020 Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. → ArcelorMittal USA n/a n/a 6.6x Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. announced the purchase of ArcelorMittal USA in Nov-2020 at 6.6x EBITDA. A raw material and downstream business moving up into integrated flat-rolled melting is a supply-chain move, and it is the logic that recurs most often in this record. Mar-2020 Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. → AK Steel Holding Corporation n/a n/a 4.6x Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. announced the purchase of AK Steel Holding Corporation in Mar-2020 at 4.6x EBITDA. Announced at a weak point in the cycle, it shows how much of the negotiation in this sector turns on whose view of mid-cycle margin per tonne prevails. Aug-2018 Blue Coral Investment Holdings Pte. Ltd and Mountainpeak Investment Holdings Ltd. → Gerdau Hungria KFT Y CIA Sociedad Regular Colectiva $120M n/a n/a Blue Coral Investment Holdings Pte. Ltd and Mountainpeak Investment Holdings Ltd. announced the purchase of Gerdau Hungria KFT Y CIA Sociedad Regular Colectiva in Aug-2018 at $120M. Small cross-border carve-outs are how producers reshape a footprint without a… May-2018 Nippon Steel & Sumitomo Metal Corp → Nisshin Steel n/a n/a 5.8x Nippon Steel & Sumitomo Metal Corp announced the purchase of Nisshin Steel in May-2018 at 5.8x EBITDA. That sits close to the middle of where the 10 rated names trade today, a reminder that whole-company agreements in this sector are often struck near the screen…
- 2006 · PRECEDENT TRANSACTIONS (2 OF 2)
All Precedent Transactions with Disclosed Terms, Newest First
Second page of the precedent transaction list, continuing the same disclosed-terms basis.
This page continues the same list of disclosed-terms transactions, newest first, on the same LTM-at-announcement basis. Together with the prior page, it gives the complete set of transactions that inform the deal-market read in this report. The remaining recorded transactions without a disclosed value or multiple sit in the companion materials.
Everything on this page
06 · PRECEDENT TRANSACTIONS (2 OF 2) All Precedent Transactions with Disclosed Terms, Newest First 21 transactions with disclosed terms in this tier (58 recorded) · multiples on LTM financials at announcement where disclosed · deal values link to the underlying filing · as of 2026-09-28 Source: NeuraCap analytics platform; market data and consensus estimates as of 2026-09-28; company disclosures via SEC EDGAR where linked. 50 precedent record(s) carry data-quality flags (deal value unit unresolved; divestiture roles reassigned; duplicate precedent id); figures are shown as recorded in the filing. 37 recorded transactions with neither a disclosed value nor a multiple are omitted from the precedent list and the case studies (kept in the companion workbook). Deal multiples are LTM at announcement (Definitive, from filings); they are not directly comparable to the CY2027E public basis and no spread is claimed. 18 of 21 transactions shown; the rest are in the companion workbook. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 20 Date Transaction EV EV/LTM Rev EV/LTM EBITDA Why it matters Sep-2017 Ternium S.A. → CSA Siderúrgica do Atlântico n/a n/a 5.9x Feb-2017 Ternium S.A. → ThyssenKrupp Slab International B.V. n/a n/a 7.0x Value shown as recorded in the filing; deal value unit unresolved. Sep-2014 Nucor → Gallatin n/a n/a 6.5x Jul-2014 AK Steel → Severstal Dearborn n/a n/a 29.4x Jul-2014 Steel Dynamics → Severstal Columbus n/a n/a 6.4x May-2011 Olympic Steel → Chicago Tube & Iron n/a n/a 14.1x Dec-2007 Evraz Group S.A. → Claymont Steel Holdings, Inc. n/a n/a 9.7x Value shown as recorded in the filing; deal value unit unresolved. Aug-2007 U.S. Steel → Stelco Inc. n/a n/a 9.3x Value shown as recorded in the filing; deal value unit unresolved. Apr-2007 Ternium S.A. → Grupo IMSA S.A.B. de C.V. n/a n/a 6.9x Value shown as recorded in the filing; deal value unit unresolved.
- 2106 · METHODOLOGY
Sources, Assumptions and Data Quality
Sources, Assumptions and Data Quality.
Sources, Assumptions and Data Quality How this report was built, what was excluded, and where every underlying disclosure lives · as of 2026-09-28 Every figure in this report links to the record it was taken from. Where a figure has no link, the appendix names its source and the basis on which it was read. 21
Everything on this page
06 · METHODOLOGY Sources, Assumptions and Data Quality How this report was built, what was excluded, and where every underlying disclosure lives · as of 2026-09-28 Every figure in this report links to the record it was taken from. Where a figure has no link, the appendix names its source and the basis on which it was read. Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice 21 VALUATION BASIS Primary valuation basis: EV / EBITDA on CY2027E consensus (10 of 11 companies eligible; multiples failing the platform's plausibility gates are excluded, never plotted). EV / EBITDA on CY2027E is the lead convention: it is the sector-appropriate prior for Steel and it clears the coverage gate with 10 of 11 companies (91%). EV / Revenue, P / E are carried as a cross-check. The set earns: 10 of the 10 companies with a reported forward EBITDA carry a meaningful one, so the profit multiple leads and a revenue multiple would understate what the market is pricing. DATA QUALITY & EXCLUSIONS 11 records were excluded or quarantined by the platform's validation gates (unit errors, implausible ratios, ineligible securities and classification failures); the full ledger ships in the companion tables and never feeds a statistic in this report. DEFINITIVE VS DIRECTIONAL Definitive content is disclosed or consensus data passed through stated arithmetic. Directional content — tier boundaries, situation cuts, "why it matters" commentary, the agenda pages — is NeuraCap analyst judgment and is labeled as such where it appears. WHAT THIS REPORT IS NOT This report characterises a sector. It does not recommend buying, selling or holding any security, and no statement in it should be read as investment advice or a price target. WHERE THE DATA LIVES 573 registered source documents stand behind the figures in this report. Metric hyperlinks throughout the deck open the specific filing or data record; by publisher: sec.gov (572) · home.treasury.gov (1). The companion workbook beside this deck carries the complete source index.
- 22
Across These 10 Rated Names, the Higher Prices Sit Alongside the Steadier Earners.
Closing statement restating the deck's core finding for the ten rated names.
Across these ten rated names, the higher prices sit alongside the steadier earners — that is the pattern this report traces from the public market screen through to the recorded transactions. The companion tables carry the full universe and the complete backup for any figure a client wants to check. We're glad to walk through any name in this set in more detail.
Everything on this page
Across These 10 Rated Names, the Higher Prices Sit Alongside the Steadier Earners. NeuraCap AI — Steel Coverage September 2026 · Prepared by NeuraCap AI · Confidential Steel Coverage | September 2026 | Confidential | Not investment advice Sources & methodology 22
Sources and methodology
This report covers Steel (Materials › Materials › Steel) with market data and consensus estimates as of September 28, 2026. The company universe is the 11 listed companies whose core business is Steel according to NeuraCap's industry classification of each company's reported business segments (a company is included only when this industry is central to what it does, not merely adjacent to it). Companies in the set: Algoma Steel Group Inc. (ASTL), Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (CLF), Commercial Metals Company (CMC), Gerdau S.A. (GGB), ArcelorMittal S.A. (MT), Metallus Inc. (MTUS), Nucor Corporation (NUE), POSCO Holdings Inc. (PKX), Companhia Siderúrgica Nacional (SID), Steel Dynamics, Inc. (STLD), Ternium S.A. (TX). The market map groups them by business vertical — Diversified multi-route steel producers: 11 companies (MT, NUE, STLD, PKX, TX, CLF, GGB, CMC, SID, ASTL, MTUS). 10 of the 11 companies carry a valid multiple on the primary valuation basis and form the rated set behind every cohort statistic; the others are shown but do not enter the statistics.
Scope and company universe
This report covers Steel (Materials › Materials › Steel) with market data and consensus estimates as of September 28, 2026. The company universe is the 11 listed companies whose core business is Steel according to NeuraCap's industry classification of each company's reported business segments (a company is included only when this industry is central to what it does, not merely adjacent to it). Companies in the set: Algoma Steel Group Inc. (ASTL), Cleveland-Cliffs Inc. (CLF), Commercial Metals Company (CMC), Gerdau S.A. (GGB), ArcelorMittal S.A. (MT), Metallus Inc. (MTUS), Nucor Corporation (NUE), POSCO Holdings Inc. (PKX), Companhia Siderúrgica Nacional (SID), Steel Dynamics, Inc. (STLD), Ternium S.A. (TX). The market map groups them by business vertical — Diversified multi-route steel producers: 11 companies (MT, NUE, STLD, PKX, TX, CLF, GGB, CMC, SID, ASTL, MTUS). 10 of the 11 companies carry a valid multiple on the primary valuation basis and form the rated set behind every cohort statistic; the others are shown but do not enter the statistics.
What was excluded and why
11 records failed a validation gate and never feed a statistic in this report (11 excluded from aggregate). Each exclusion, with its reason: ASTL — EBITDA is non-positive; EV/EBITDA is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · ASTL — EBITDA is non-positive; EV/EBITDA is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · ASTL — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · ASTL — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · ASTL — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · ASTL — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · CLF — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · CLF — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · CLF — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · MTUS — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate) · SID — Non-positive EPS; P/E is n/m (effect: excluded from aggregate)
Primary valuation basis and how it was chosen
Primary valuation basis: EV / EBITDA on CY2027E consensus (10 of 11 companies eligible; multiples failing the platform's plausibility gates are excluded, never plotted). EV / EBITDA on CY2027E is the lead convention: it is the sector-appropriate prior for Steel and it clears the coverage gate with 10 of 11 companies (91%). EV / Revenue, P / E are carried as a cross-check. The set earns: 10 of the 10 companies with a reported forward EBITDA carry a meaningful one, so the profit multiple leads and a revenue multiple would understate what the market is pricing. The basis is selected in two steps: the industry's customary valuation conventions set the order of preference, and each convention is then tested for coverage — the share of companies with a valid, plausibility-checked multiple on the chosen period. A convention is used only when enough companies carry it; the best-covered convention is used, and disclosed, when none clears the threshold. Coverage measured for this report — EV / EBITDA: 10 of 11 companies; EV / rEVenue: 11 of 11 companies; P/E: 5 of 11 companies. 1 company shows a non-meaningful P / E denominator and is excluded from that statistic.
How the multiples and statistics are computed
Enterprise value (EV) is market capitalisation at the as-of date plus total debt minus cash and equivalents from the latest reported balance sheet, reconciled against the platform's stored value and disclosed where the two differ. Forward multiples divide EV (or the share price for P/E) by the consensus estimate for the stated calendar period; trailing multiples use the last twelve months of reported figures from SEC filings. A multiple with a negative or immaterial denominator is treated as not meaningful and excluded from every statistic. Cohort statistics are medians and quartiles over the rated set only; a group median with fewer than three observations is shown as the single company's figure and labelled as such. Valuation tiers cut the rated set at its quartiles (tiers cut at the rated set's quartiles: Premium ≥6.7x, Core 4.5x–6.7x, Discount <4.5x — NeuraCap groupings). Revenue growth compares consecutive calendar-year consensus revenue; EBITDA margin divides consensus EBITDA by consensus revenue for the same period. Figures shown in this report and the calculation behind each: 5.7x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) (10 rated companies) · 7.4x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) within Premium tier (n=3) · 5.7x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) within Core tier (n=4) · 4.3x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) within Discount tier (n=3) · 5.3x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) | growth ≥ 4% (n=5) · 6.5x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) | growth < 4% (n=5) · 4.5x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) | EBITDA margin ≥ 17% (n=5) · 6.0x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) | EBITDA margin < 17% (n=5) · 21% = median Rule of 40 score (revenue growth + EBITDA margin) (n=10) · 4.0x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) within balanced quadrant (n=2) · 7.4x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) within marginOnly quadrant (n=3) · 6.0x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) within growthOnly quadrant (n=3) · 5.6x = median(ev_ebitda CY2027E) within neither quadrant (n=2)
Precedent transactions: what is in the record and why
The precedent record holds the M&A transactions in Steel recorded from SEC filings (8-K announcements and the documents they reference), newest first, with each value and multiple linked to the exact passage in the filing that states it. 58 transactions were recorded for this industry; 21 are shown. 37 recorded transactions with neither a disclosed value nor a multiple are omitted because they say nothing about price; they remain in the companion workbook. Deal multiples are enterprise value over the target's last-twelve-month revenue or EBITDA at announcement, as disclosed; they are not restated to the public basis and no spread to the public multiples is claimed. Before a transaction reaches the record it passes a screen for mirrored or duplicate filings of the same deal, for divestitures where the filer is the seller rather than the buyer, for carve-outs recorded under the parent's name, and for values whose citation describes something other than the price paid (a debt raise, a termination fee); such records are corrected or excluded and the correction is noted. Data-quality notes on this record: 25 × no evidence record; 19 × deal value unit unresolved; 2 × duplicate precedent id; 2 × divestiture roles reassigned; 2 × parent financials detached. Case studies lead with the 1 richest stories — disclosed value, a readable multiple, newest first.
Sources
Company financials and transaction terms come from the companies' own SEC filings on EDGAR (10-K, 10-Q and 8-K documents), linked from each figure in the report. Forward figures are analyst consensus estimates for the calendar periods shown. Share prices and market capitalisations are market data as of September 28, 2026. Treasury yields are published by the U.S. Department of the Treasury. 577 source documents stand behind this report; by publisher domain: sec.gov, home.treasury.gov (1). Every figure on every page is traceable to one of these records; nothing in the report is derived from outside data.
Interpretation and important notice
Tier labels, situation maps, the agenda and the implications pages are NeuraCap analytical views drawn from the recorded evidence and are labelled as such. The report is informational: it is not investment advice, not a recommendation to buy or sell any security, not an opinion of value and not an offer of any kind. Readers should perform their own diligence before acting on anything described here.
Sources linked in the report
- Steel Dynamics (STLD) (sec.gov)
- Cleveland-Cliffs (CLF) (sec.gov)
- Commercial Metals (CMC) (sec.gov)
- Metallus (MTUS) (sec.gov)
- $2.2B (sec.gov)
- n/a (sec.gov)
- $9.2B (sec.gov)
- n/a (sec.gov)
- n/a (sec.gov)
- 6.6x (sec.gov)
- n/a (sec.gov)
- $120M (sec.gov)
- n/a (sec.gov)
- n/a (sec.gov)
- 5.9x (sec.gov)
- sec.gov (572) (sec.gov)
- home.treasury.gov (1) (home.treasury.gov)
This report is published for information only. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell any security, an offer or solicitation, an appraisal or a fairness opinion, and no fiduciary relationship is created by reading it. Multiples that fail NeuraCap’s plausibility gates are excluded and never plotted. See the full methodology and the disclaimer.
More coverage in Materials
- M&A Update · 29 September 2026Advanced and Engineered Materials M&A update, 14–28 September 2026
- Sector Outlook · 29 September 2026Advanced and Engineered Materials Sector Outlook — September 2026
- M&A Update · 29 September 2026Agricultural Chemicals and Fertilizers M&A update, 14–28 September 2026
- Sector Outlook · 28 September 2026Agricultural Chemicals and Fertilizers Sector Outlook — September 2026
Want this analysis for a company in Steel?
Company valuation reports run the same method against a single business — public or private.
